Can universities remain independent with the military on campus?
The military is becoming increasingly involved in academic research, including at Tilburg University. But what happens to academic independence when universities rely on funding from an institution with its own strategic interests? The history of the tobacco industry offers a warning, writes Yeşim Topuz.

The military has been slowly making its way into academia. It has done so by offering a well-paying defense minor or participating in research projects such as STEADFAST, right here at Tilburg University. But the Ministry of Defense is not just any other collaboration partner. At the end of the day, its institutional mandate is defense readiness and national security. This raises the question of how we keep research unbiased as the military’s presence in the academic sphere expands.
To understand why military funding in universities is problematic, we do not need to look very far into the future. We can look backward, for example at the tobacco industry’s long-standing playbook of buying academic legitimacy.
Tobacco firms have poured vast sums of money into academic research, including funding studies at Dutch universities like Utrecht University, to contest the link between smoking and cancer. In some ways, they didn’t even need to dictate the final sentence of a report line by line; corporate money shaped the research ecosystem itself.
Science relies on testing hypotheses objectively to find the truth. When funding is structurally tied to predetermined outcomes, the scientific method is inverted, creating systemic vulnerabilities to bias in study design and data reporting.
Universities are widely trusted by the public, by doctors and lawmakers as independent centers of knowledge. When academic research gets funded by, for example, tobacco firms, they ‘launder’ their public relations messaging through respected institutions, making industry propaganda look like objective science. It is more about the branding than the raw data, really. If a respected academic institution publishes studies, they can wave them in front of regulators and the public, saying, ‘Look, independent experts confirmed it!’
So, when the Ministry of Defense funds university labs, the boundary between critical inquiry and strategic statecraft may begin to dissolve. Can a university maintain its critical distance when its funding, labs, and career tracks are entangled with national actors and interests?
It may be argued that if the state wanted biased research, it could simply do it in-house. Well, so could the tobacco firms. But this argument misses the entire point of external funding: in-house research lacks credibility because it can be seen as partisan propaganda. By outsourcing to universities, state actors acquire an illusion of neutrality that internal agencies can’t.
This threatens institutional identities. Tilburg University has historically built its reputation on the social sciences, law, humanities, and understanding society. Defense money pays well, and for many, especially those in more precarious situations, they might gravitate toward fundable, secure topics. And academia is not necessarily known for its security, so having a well-funded research project is something many won’t be able to refuse.
Furthermore, this funding serves to normalize militarization in the civilian sphere. Universities are one way to reach the civilian sphere, through lecture halls and campus partnerships.
Universities are meant to be spaces for independent thought, critical dissent, and the pursuit of knowledge free from corporate coercion. We can’t possibly accept the premise that military money comes with no strings attached. And when universities consider their collaboration partners, some call for more scrutiny. It might be a mistake to treat the Ministry of Defense as any other ordinary research partner.
Yeşim Topuz is a research master’s student in Social and Behavioural Sciences.